It must be a typo
By Steve | January 24, 2008
“It must be a typo” was my reaction today upon reading the New York Times headline online: “Fraud costs bank $7.1 Billion.” Perhaps the headline was supposed to be about banks, plural, and the story was about fraud losses over the years. Or maybe the amount was $7.1 million.
But no. France’s second largest bank, Société Générale, disclosed today that one rogue trader caused $7.1 billion dollars in losses. As is common in our experience, the trader did not appear to have personally profited from the trades.
Bank spokespeople are claiming that Jerome Kerviel was able to perpetuate this fraud because he used to work in the risk management office and thus was able to breach five levels of controls. Plus he was “a computer genius.”
Outside experts are criticizing the banks internal controls. Société Générale states that their internal controls “have been revised and reinforced to avoid any reoccurrence of further similar risk.” They have also fired five individuals, including Kerviel’s supervisor and the head of global equities and derivatives trading.
My hunch is they may want to look at the most critical internal control: culture. It is very difficult to believe that any one individual, even a “computer genius,” could pull off a fraud of such magnitude without awareness by anybody else at Société Générale.
I have had the privilege of conducting a lot of ethics training in France. Most of the time, in response to hypothetical case studies, I hear that “reporting the misconduct of others is not our job. To do so is not the French way. It is the responsibility of management to find this out and do something about it.”
I wonder what the employees of Société Générale think about this cultural value now. What do the shareholders think? This case provides $7.1 Billion reasons for working to build a culture where people take responsibility for acting when they suspect illegal conduct.




Comments
A French citizen, I feel extreme what you are saying about the French "unethical" culture - let me help you understand better what you seem to have missed: Frenchs inherit that culture of "non reporting" from the darkest hours of Europe: a time when people were asked by the Nazis to report on Jews. Some French citizens did follow the instructions(some in an especially zealous way I must say), and that behavior led to the deportation of thousands of people.
That shame is and will always be anchored in our culture: that is why, when you ask a French to report, his first reaction will be to tell you that he is not a "collabo" (the name of those who gave the jews to the nazis).
But believe me, facing such a scandal, with such potential negative impact for the bank (and their jobs), 100% of the French people would have had reported that case if they have known about!
The real reason why no-one reported on that guy is that everyone believed that the system was PERFECT.
The Societe Generale is kwnown in the industry for having some of the toughest and most rigourous risk procedures: the truth is, that, just like 1 single computer genius can infiltrate some of the most secret databases from the government or the army, one guy who know everything about a system can overcome any procedures put in place: that is true for banks and even nuclear or military facilities!
Posted by: yann from France | January 25, 2008 08:35 PM